Faith

Priesthood Authority: Restored Offices or a Royal Priesthood in Christ

Part 14 of the Doctrinal Differences Series

Growing up in a church where only males age 12 and up had access to the priesthood profoundly shaped my relationship with prayer and God in ways I am only beginning to unravel. Through many priesthood lessons, blessings, and other experiences I firmly believed that my prayers mattered less than anything a man in authority said, because I was a girl who could not hold the priesthood. That belief settled quietly into my heart and shaped how I approached God. I often felt like my words carried less weight, so I rarely prayed at all.

A few years ago, I stood at my daughter’s hospital bed and felt that old ache rise again, and even develop into anger. Several friends from the Mormon church visited and a few offered to give her a priesthood blessing. Their offers came from sincere love and a real desire to help, and I am grateful for that kindness. Those moments, however really brought my unhealthy relationship with prayer and church authority into stark awareness. Their confidence in their priesthood authority felt alike a statement of my inadequacy. No matter how hard I prayed I did not have the “power” to reach God. They did. I felt the familiar sense that my own voice before God would never be enough. That experience stayed with me and eventually led me to study what the Bible teaches about prayer, authority, and how God hears His children without hierarchy or spiritual ranking.

The LDS Priesthood: Authority Restored Through Ordination

A 19th century depiction of John the Baptist conferring the Aaronic priesthood to Joseph Smith and Oliver Cowdery retrieved from Wikipedia.

LDS doctrine teaches that priesthood authority was restored in 1829. Joseph Smith and Oliver Cowdery recorded that the resurrected John the Baptist appeared and conferred the Aaronic Priesthood, followed by Jesus’ disciples Peter, James, and John conferring the Melchizedek Priesthood. This restoration is essential to LDS belief. Without it, the church could not perform saving ordinances or act in God’s name. It is their main claim to being the only true church of Christ on the Earth today.

The Aaronic Priesthood includes the offices of deacon, teacher, and priest. The Melchizedek Priesthood includes the offices of elder, high priest, patriarch, seventy, and apostle. These offices carry specific responsibilities and are conferred through ordination by the laying on of hands. Only men are ordained, and authority is passed through an unbroken line of priesthood holders.

LDS teaching adds further requirements to this system. Every ordination must follow a worthiness interview, and worthiness must be maintained for a man to exercise his priesthood authority. This creates pressure on the priesthood holder, who may fear that any personal struggle or perceived weakness could invalidate his ability to act in God’s name. The same emphasis on worthiness affects those receiving blessings or ordinances. Many members quietly worry about whether the person administering a blessing is worthy enough for it to be effective or accurate.

LDS structure reinforces this pattern. Every calling in the church, from a twelve‑year‑old class president to the president of the entire organization, is considered an assignment given by God through leaders who hold priesthood authority. Every individual must be set apart with a priesthood blessing before beginning that role. The belief is that God speaks through priesthood leaders to appoint each person, and that priesthood power is required for them to function in their calling.

This belief becomes especially damaging when leadership is harmful or abusive. Many members feel unable to question or challenge a leader because the calling is believed to come directly from God. The case of Wade S. Christofferson shows how this dynamic can protect abusers and silence victims. FLOODLIT documents decades of allegations against him, including abuse that was known to church leaders. He was allowed to repent, return to leadership positions, and then abuse again. The cycle repeated across multiple wards, leaving victims feeling powerless because their leader had been set apart by priesthood authority and presented as chosen by God.

Official teachings reinforce this culture of silence. Dallin H. Oaks taught, “It is wrong to criticize leaders of the Church, even if the criticism is true.” That message creates fear around speaking up, even when harm is occurring. The difficulty becomes even more pronounced in situations where leaders are not breaking laws but are still exercising unrighteous dominion. Many members feel confused or guilty for noticing controlling, manipulative, or spiritually coercive behavior, because they have been taught that God Himself placed that leader in their path.

My own experience reflects this dynamic. A bishop once told me that my husband’s cheating was my fault because I had “given him permission to date” when I said it was fine for him to go out with friends after work. I did not know when he said “friends” he actually meant a single woman. He also told me it was my responsibility to keep my husband on a short leash to prevent future sins on his part. Comments like these are not illegal, but they are deeply damaging. They come from someone believed to be called by God, someone members are taught not to criticize, someone whose authority is treated as divinely sanctioned. That belief can make harmful counsel feel like spiritual truth and can leave members doubting their own judgment.

Situations like these reveal how the doctrine of divinely appointed leadership can discourage accountability, silence victims, and leave people feeling spiritually trapped, even when the harm is subtle, emotional, or framed as righteous guidance.

LDS scripture emphasizes the necessity of this restored authority. Doctrine and Covenants 13 states that the Aaronic Priesthood holds the keys of the ministering of angels and of baptism. Doctrine and Covenants 84 teaches that the priesthood is required for the administration of the gospel. Doctrine and Covenants 107 outlines the structure and offices of both priesthoods.

LDS teaching presents priesthood authority as the literal power of God delegated to specific individuals. It governs ordinances, blessings, leadership, and the operation of the church. The system creates a hierarchy of spiritual access, where some believers are seen as having greater ability to approach God or act in His name than others.

The Biblical Priesthood: Christ Our High Priest and Believers United in Him

Biblical Christianity begins with a different starting point. The New Testament teaches that Jesus Christ is the final and eternal High Priest. His sacrifice is once for all. His intercession is perfect. His priesthood is unchangeable. He is the fulfillment of every priestly role of the Old Covenant.

Hebrews declares, “He entered once for all into the holy places by means of his own blood.” (Hebrews 9:12)

Old Testament priests served as mediators who stood between God and the people. Their role pointed forward to Christ, the true and greater High Priest. Hebrews explains that the priests “serve a copy and shadow of the heavenly things” (Hebrews 8:5), showing that their ministry was never meant to be permanent. Their sacrifices had to be repeated, their priesthood passed from one generation to the next, and their intercession was limited by their own humanity.

Christ’s priesthood stands complete, so no additional priesthood offices are needed. No human ordination can add to His finished work. Hebrews teaches that “He always lives to make intercession” (Hebrews 7:25), and that His once‑for‑all sacrifice ended the need for any other mediator. The veil is torn, access is open, and the priestly system of the Old Covenant has reached its fulfillment in Him.

This truth carries a crucial implication. The priesthood does not need to be restored because it was never lost. It was fulfilled. Christ’s completed work replaced the temporary system of human mediators with His eternal priesthood. The New Covenant does not wait for a restoration; it rests on a fulfillment.

The New Testament teaches that all believers share in Christ’s priestly identity. Peter writes, “You are a chosen race, a royal priesthood.” (1 Peter 2:9)

This priesthood belongs to every Christian. Men and women, young and old, Jew and Gentile. Through union with Christ, believers offer spiritual sacrifices, proclaim His gospel, and have direct access to God. There is no restored hierarchy. There is no division between priesthood holders and non‑holders. There is no need for lineage or ordination. The priesthood of all believers is grounded entirely in Christ.

My own life reflects the beauty of this truth. The strongest connection with God I have ever felt came during a simple moment in a women’s Bible study. A group of women gathered around me and prayed with sincerity, tenderness, and confidence in Christ alone. Their prayers did not rely on offices, ordinations, or ecclesiastical authority. Their access to God came from their identity in Him. That moment showed me what Scripture teaches so clearly: Christ opens the way for every believer, and His presence rests on His people without hierarchy or restriction.

Why This Difference Matters

When you look closely at these two teachings, you start to see how much they shape a believer’s everyday relationship with God. In the LDS system, spiritual authority is concentrated in the hands of those who have been ordained. That means ordinances, blessings, and even certain forms of spiritual access depend on someone else being present and authorized. It creates a natural reliance on priesthood holders because they stand between the individual and the sacred responsibilities of the church. there is a human representative standing in between people and God.

Biblical Christianity approaches the idea of priesthood very differently. Instead of limiting spiritual authority to a select group, it teaches that every believer stands directly before God with the same access and the same dignity because Christ Himself is the High Priest. There is no spiritual ladder to climb and no special class of people who mediate God’s presence. The emphasis falls entirely on Christ and what He has already accomplished, and from that place He lifts His people into a shared identity.

These two teachings lead to two very different kinds of communities. The LDS model builds a structured hierarchy where authority flows through offices and ordinations. The biblical model builds a family where every believer participates fully because their standing comes from Christ rather than a position. One looks back to an Old Testament pattern of priesthood. The other rests in the New Covenant reality that Christ’s priesthood is complete and His people share in it together.

The Completed Promise

The priesthood of all believers is not symbolic. It is a declaration of identity rooted in the finished work of Christ. He is the High Priest who never dies and never needs replacement. His people are priests because they belong to Him.

There is no need for restoration when the promise has already been completed.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *